Review: Lip Critic – Theft World – The Alternative

Posted: 6th May, 2026 by The Alt Editing Staff

The Alternative is 100% supported by our readers. If you’d like to help us write about more great music and keep our site going, you can become a Patron on Patreon, which also allows you to receive extra content, sweet perks, and The Alternative merch, with levels starting at only $2 per month. Everything helps, and if you can’t afford to donate, consider sharing this article and spreading the word about our site! And if you want The Alternative delivered straight to your inbox every month, sign up for our free newsletter. Either way, thanks for reading!

The last time I saw Lip Critic live, they left me looking like Skyy Clark. Between punches from windmillers in the mosh pit and a mic to the face during “The Heart,” I left the show—held in the basement of a country club in Lakewood, New Jersey—with a bloody mouth and half of my front right tooth in my jacket pocket. As I stared at my mouth in the mirror at home, only one thought crossing my mind: Should’ve seen that one coming. There are only so many artists, so many shows, where something like that happens, and you leave the set completely stoked by the experience, retelling it to anyone with working ears and recommending they see them the next time they’re playing, too. Lip Critic, as a live act, has established themselves as one of the wildest and most insane bands touring today; on the four-piece’s sophomore album, Theft World, they bottle and sell that fiery insanity.

Lip Critic is no stranger to tales of absurdity and describing freaks that don’t exist, having an entire arsenal of songs about a creature with a disgustingly long tongue and a corrupt, money-hungry preacher. Theft World, though, elevates this strangeness to an entirely different level. While touring their debut album Hex Dealer in 2024, lead singer Bret Kaser’s identity was stolen by none other than a fan. This fan confronted Kaser on tour to inform him that he had picked up the breadcrumbs the band had been leaving in their music to solve the ultimate multidimensional puzzle. Rather than turning him into the authorities, the band took the scammer to a halal shop and recorded the ramblings of the world’s most normal Lip Critic listener, eventually leading the group to scrap their planned album and create Theft World.

The psychotic universe explored on the New York band’s latest album paints normal places—the ATM, the freezer aisle in the supermarket, the casino—into nightmarish landscapes to meet with an angry deity. On “Drumming With Izzy” and “My Blush (Strength of the Critic),” Kaser plugs back into the dogmatic pseudo-preacher character crafted for Hex Dealer, serving a grandiose Martin Short in “Leap of Faith”-esque character with a side of ass-shaking. Lip Critic echoes the regular talks with God explored throughout their debut release, but the absurdity is turned up to eleven on Theft World thanks to the spiraling, paranoid thoughts the album was born from.

Buried beneath the anxiety and violence is a deeply personal album, with the best-written songs from the digital hardcore band thus far. There is an inherently surreal quality to the words, brought on by the weirdness radiating throughout the album, but foraging through Atari game-sounding synths and Kaser’s high-speed preaching, you’ll find “Yard Sale (230 Take)” has some of the most beautiful and haunting lyrics this year (“Only after fire I had discovered love / Thrust through the heart of the air like a dove / What could comе before it? / Nothing elsе could come above”). Tracks like “Two Lucks” (“You / are the Hell / That I made / For myself”) and “200 Bottles on Eviction” (“And the world lives on in spite of you / And death will still bloom inside of you”) wander into emo songwriting territory as Kaser writhes and screeches in total devotion to a world no one truly understands.

What adds power to Kaser’s words is not just the wanton intensity with which he delivers them, but the blistering drums pulsating under any movement, no matter how minuscule. Dual drummers Danny Eberle and Michael Sandvig beat down, breakdown, and battle with one another on every track to create this monstrous sound that feels bigger than God himself. Between Theft World and that most recent Osees album, every band should musicmaxx and invest in two drummers now.

Thanks to Connor Kleitz’s unruly production and sampling, every song on Theft World is as vibrant and stylized as it is venomous, a custom paint job on a beaten-up Ferrari. There’s a bizarre creativity to the tiny choices made by Kleitz for this album—the coked-out guitar that lights up on “Charity Dinner” or the generic party blower squeak at the end of “Two Lucks” come to mind—that makes Theft World sound like something Glep would listen to on his iPad in the Smiling Friends breakroom.

The album has a handful of unbelievable transitions mid-song that play out as these “Come to Jesus” moments in the midst of Kaser’s lunacy, slamming down on you like a freezing bucket of water. The sparse moments when Theft World allows the listener to breathe, like the organ-sounding synth on “200 Bottles on Eviction” and the dotty breakdown on “Jackpot,” are so jarringly healing and angelic for an album so abrasive. These air pockets trapped within the savagery of the album only make these songs more enigmatic and entrancing, never feeling like a detriment to the aggressive nature that Theft World creates.

What makes Lip Critic so viciously unique is their commitment to absurdity, the maximization of everything. They are the Conner O’Malley of music—loud, in-your-face, and entirely nonsensical—yet their ability to give 110% 100% of the time leaves people chasing for more (so much so they might go a little insane over it, as Theft World explores). The New York punk rockers throw everything, the kitchen sink, and themselves at the wall to create an album that is totally worth breaking a tooth or two for.

Disappointing / Average / Good / Great / Phenomenal

––

Jules Kelly | @snaiImaiI