Posted: by The Alt Editing Staff
The Alternative is 100% supported by our readers. If you’d like to help us write about more great music and keep our site going, you can become a Patron on Patreon, which also allows you to receive extra content, sweet perks, and The Alternative merch, with levels starting at only $2 per month. Everything helps, and if you can’t afford to donate, consider sharing this article and spreading the word about our site! And if you want The Alternative delivered straight to your inbox every month, sign up for our free newsletter. Either way, thanks for reading!

Grace Ives comes out fresh and better than ever with her sophomore album Girlfriend. Her last album Janky Star having dropped in 2022, Ives shows who she really is for the first time. A notable collaborator on this project was John DeBold, who worked closely with HAIM on their grammy nominated record Women in Music Pt. II. Ives released four great singles off of this project, “Avalanche,” “Dance With Me,” “My Mans,” and “Stupid Bitches,” the latter especiallybeing a fan favorite.
Upon my first listen of Girlfriend, I discovered that it was best heard in your actual girlfriend’s car, bass up, windows down. Something about Ives’ voice and production gives a sense of arcadia and enchantment that deserves a physical scene and sensory experience with speakers up as loud as possible. Girlfriend is a temporary world created by Ives. Girlfriends and boyfriends come and go, relationships start and end, time passes, we struggle, we get better again, and through that we have memories to hold onto. This is exactly the world Girlfriend creates. And through the album, she takes on ideas such as substance abuse, feminine sexuality, and learning to not take yourself too seriously in a skillful, deliberate, and genuine storyline.
On “Stupid Bitches,” Ives perfectly captures what it is to make a pop-hit song today. Not only that, the song captures the very essence of the album. What is it to watch time pass? Some try to emulate the inter-dimensional and unique “alternative” pop sound with lyrics that match. We see that with many pop giants such as Taylor Swift, who have attempted with their long-time fame to keep up with acts such as Ives in terms of sound. Swift takes on a soft, delicate synth resonance with her newest work, Life of a Showgirl, in combination with wannabe relatable generational terms and cringy millennial terminology used in her lyrics. This can be seen in songs such as the manufactured hit “The Fate of Ophelia” (“Pledge allegiance to your hands / Your team / Your vibes”) or the one-liner “I’ve come back stronger than a ‘90s trend” from “Willow” off evermore. Ives synth-sound relates more to that of Björk on Debut, with lyrics being new-age but still maintaining their witty affect. And unlike Swift, Ives of course takes over the narrative, tackles her hardships and makes it relatable in a way that is artistically dense. Ives’ voice and tone of her own lyrics when discussing topics, such as substance abuse, sexuality, and growing up, is mature and fully realized.
Don’t get me wrong, some of these songs could have potential, they just lack a major factor of authenticity. Swift may mention her own hardships, trials and tribulations, but these lyrics completely and totally miss the mark with their delivery. On Ives’ “Drink Up,” she sings, “When the rain is washing in / Can you save a drop for me? / Baby wants to cut me off,” then later that verse it goes into “I did everything, and you / Wouldn’t give me mine / Mm, so, I…” depicting a frustrating struggle with control over substances. This is the level of authenticity many pop artists try to emulate: poetic lyrics that maintain their wit and are catchy, clever, and relatable. Not only that, but have production to match. Getting both right is hard to come by, and that’s what Ives does best here. It is worth mentioning that lyrics can be both straight-forward and memorable, though at times she is complex and poetic with her words; these forthright lyrics are paired with substantial production. These are both things Ives does well. Ives makes it look easy to make a momentous pop record.
“Neither You Nor I” takes on another key theme of the album. Going from depicting struggle to something a little more carefree where Ives voices her sexuality. It is not that often we see women in music able to freely express their sexuality and enjoyment for sex. “Neither You Nor I”’s story is similar to that of “Hot Knife” by Fiona Apple. Apple uses the hot knife as a metaphor (“If I’m butter then he’s a hot knife”), a visual representation of the ease she feels with her partner. There is even a direct reference to a “hot knife” in “Neither You Nor I,” “Hot like a knife / stab in my chubby side / It’s just a wash,” the knife being the tool to unveil her passion for this other nameless, genderless, person she is interested in.
The penultimate track “Garden” begins winding Girlfriend down on a sorrowful note: “Well, oh yeah / Get the feeling that it’s over now / Yeah, oh yeah / Get the feeling that it’s over now.” Ives replays the loss of relationships or feelings for someone and the lyrics, “Lucky to be free from the hell of my pride” call back to emotional struggles. While grieving and recalling loss, Ives looks towards starting over, realizing things are temporary and that’s okay. Then, of course, “Stupid Bitches” closes off, an official ending, a glimmer of hope, and a climax to the story that then quickly resolves itself, “I’m a loser with an aching touch/But something about it makes me brave/Tough enough to see myself replaced/I just let it be embarrassing.”
Disappointing / Average / Good / Great / Phenomenal
––
Ivory Wynne























































































.jpg?mbid=social_retweet)










