Tucker Wetmore Gets Personal on New Album ‘What Not To’

In the span of little more than a year, Tucker Wetmore has quickly positioned himself as an artist whose songs like “Wine into Whiskey” and “Wind Up Missin’ You” are connecting with fans, but the title track to his new album What Not To captures a life story he initially thought was too personal to sing about.

“I was like, ‘No, I’m not going to share this, I’m not going to talk about this,’” he tells Billboard.

The song finds Wetmore shedding light on a childhood with a father battling against alcohol and pills, and Wetmore’s resulting desire and determination to forge a different path. Now, “What Not To” is the title track of his debut full-length album, out Friday (April 25) on UMG’s EMI Records Nashville, in partnership with Back Blocks Music.

“When I started thinking more about it, I got excited to open up in that sense,” Tucker says of the song. “It’s a thing a lot more people go through or went through. When I think of why I started playing music 10, 15 years ago, it made me feel something. It saved me, it helped me, it was my therapy. This is one of those songs that could be that for somebody else. I feel like every day there’s instance where you’re presented with choices — some big some small, some life changing. I feel like when I get to that crossroad, having that ‘What Not To’ mindset, that’s the first thing that pops in my head.”

He teamed with his producer Chris LaCorte, who co-wrote the song with Wetmore, Chase McGill and Jameson Rogers, and the song spilled out during a four-day writing retreat at a rented lake house in Lynchburg, Tennessee.

“It was the last day and we were all just mentally tired,” Wetmore recalls. “We had just eaten breakfast and Chase started talking about his dad, and then I started talking about mine, and we all just talked real life — like buddies do. It was probably one of the toughest, but also easiest, writes of my life, because talking about that stuff is not easy for me. But it was a bunch of guys wearing our hearts on our sleeves, and the song came from that.”

The rest of the album finds Wetmore looking at other hard-earned lessons in love and life, blending elements of the country, gospel, rock and reggae music that Wetmore heard at home in Kamala, Washington, as he was growing up — though, throughout high school and college, his primary passion was sports, as a multi-sport athlete successful in football and track & field.

When Wetmore was sidelined by a football injury in college, he funneled his former athletic determination into his passion for music and writing songs.

“Wine Into Whiskey” became his first to chart on both the Hot Country Songs chart and the all-genre Hot 100, setting this hitmaking machine into motion and followed with “Wind Up Missing You,” which rose to No 2. on the Country Airplay chart. The songs have become back-to-back RIAA-certified Platinum hits for Wetmore and were both included on his debut EP, Waves on a Sunset.

His new album is poised to be a star-maker for Wetmore, who has amassed over 7 million monthly listeners on Spotify alone. Throughout What Not To, he distills lessons learned by both his own experiences and close observation of those around him.

Wetmore and his team narrowed down potential songs to around three dozen before deciding on the album’s final 19 tracks. “We had a lower number of songs and then we’d go back and think, ‘No, this song has to be on it,’” Wetmore says.

A couple of those last-minute adds were “3, 2, 1” (which is in the top 40 on the Country Airplay chart), and “Takes One to Break One,” which Wetmore calls “kind of the centerpiece of the record. It’s talking about bad luck, bad habits, all of those things. I’m a very album-based listener and that’s what I want to create as an artist, so it had to be on there.”

Songs like “Casino” and “Bad Luck Looks Good On Me” nod to the win-some, lose-some gambles inherent in betting on love, while songs such as “Whatcha Think Is Gonna Happen,” “Silverado Blue” and “Whiskey Again” touch on a time-honored coping mechanism. “Brunette” and “3, 2, 1” continue spiraling back to themes of heartbreak and attempts at moving on.

Tucker says “All of It” is inspired by his real life. “It’s just telling my truth — and there’s metaphors as well, like, ‘Is he really talking about the girl, or is he talking about whiskey, or his relationship with family?’ There’s some weird metaphor things and Easter eggs in the record, which I think is really cool, and it’s going to be cool to see people dissect the whole thing.”

In addition to the writers’ retreat, Wetmore wrote for the album with such top writers as Thomas Archer, Corey Crowder and Justin Ebach, and he says he poured that same passion he held for bettering his skill on the ballfield into elevating his craft as a writer.

“I try to just always be a sponge in the writing room and try to learn something every day,” he says. “Yesterday, I wrote a song with Chris [LaCorte], Jessie Jo Dillon and Jessi Alexander. The coolest thing is to just be able to sit in a room with them, learning from them about how they structure things, and how they work creatively. I’m fortunate enough to call them good friends and blessed to have the people around me that I have.”

When he goes to the ACM Awards next month and vies for a win in the new male artist of the year category, he’ll be bringing his mom with him as his date on the red carpet.

“It’s going to be awesome,” he says. “She’s happy she gets to watch her son do what he loves and she’s always supported me. She’s one the biggest reasons why I’m in Nashville and chasing my dream of music.”

In May, he’ll also headline his first show at Ryman Auditorium—the same stage where he previewed “What Not To” in February before an audience of veteran country radio executives during the UMG Nashville showcase at Country Radio Seminar.

“I was terrified,” he recalls of that CRS performance. “It was just me fighting an internal battle, but I’m very happy that I did it. And I’m so excited to headline the Ryman. I don’t think the feelings are really going to hit me until I walk in and I’m like, ‘Oh, wow, this is my show.”

Songs from the new album like “Casino” and “Brunette” have already connected with fans when he slips them into his set. “It’s probably the craziest song in our set,” he says of the latter track. “It’s just creating a buzz. I love these songs, and they are fun to play.”

He’ll bring his new music to broader audiences on Thomas Rhett’s Better in Boots Tour this year, and as he takes the songs to his fans, he’ll take forward a bit of advice he learned while opening shows for Jon Pardi.

“He said, ‘Just take it in and enjoy it all, even the smallest things,’” Wetmore says of Pardi. “He also said to, every night, take a second or two onstage to remind yourself that this is one of the coolest things in the world.”

While he may have racked up career milestones at an impressive clip already, Wetmore says future music will continue revealing more of himself.

“It feels like we’re scratching the surface to telling my story and letting people in on who I am as a person,” he says. “And as an artist, as a songwriter, as a son, as a brother, as a friend — just me.”